Menu

Linguistics Limbo

NTSB Law Judge Agrees Medical Application Question Is Ambiguous

The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) has for years argued that its airman medical certificate application (FAA Form 8500-7, “MedXPress”) is clear and unambiguous. In fact, the FAA has regularly assumed any incorrect answer on the MedXPress is an intentionally false statement, warranting revocation of all airman certificates on an emergency basis.

However, in a recent case before the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB), Bedford v. Porretta, the presiding Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) determined that question 18.y in the MedXPress was ambiguous. It asks whether the applicant has any history of receiving “medical disability benefits.”

Steven Porretta, Jr., the airman in question, is a veteran of the United States Navy and, after being honorably discharged, started receiving disability compensation from the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA). He never reported receiving VA disability compensation on MedXPress. Like nearly 4,700 other veterans, Porretta’s medical file was flagged in a “special project” comparing MedXPress responses to VA records.

The FAA argued that VA disability compensation is a “medical disability benefit,” which must be reported on MedXPress. Porretta argued he did not understand his VA disability compensation as a “medical disability benefit”; rather, he argued that he understood the question to refer to disability benefits that preclude gainful activity (i.e., working), such as Social Security Disability Insurance. Like most veterans receiving VA disability compensation, Porretta is not prohibited from working.

It’s important here to review the regulatory landscape. Two related regulations are at play here. The first, FAR § 3.403, prohibits any intentionally false statement made in any document, including on MedXPress. To prove an intentionally false statement, the FAA must establish three elements, called the Hart v. McLucas test: (1) the airman made a false representation (2) in relation to a material fact (3) with knowledge of the falsity. A violation of FAR § 3.403 allows the FAA to revoke all airman certificates, including pilot certificates.

The second regulation, FAR § 3.405, prohibits any incorrect statement on any document, including MedXPress. Here, the FAA need only prove the statement was objectively incorrect. There is no scienter requirement—intent or knowledge is irrelevant. A violation allows the FAA to suspend or revoke only the certificate upon which the incorrect application was based.

In the case at hand, the NTSB ALJ determined Porretta’s response to question 18.y was incorrect. In other words, VA disability compensation is objectively a “medical disability benefit,” and Porretta should have provided an affirmative response to question 18.y. For that, the ALJ affirmed FAA’s revocation of Porretta’s medical certificate.

While the FAA was able to prove the first two elements of the Hart v. McLucas test, the FAA failed to prove the third. Here, Porretta took a unique approach. He presented a witness qualified as an expert in forensic linguistics, lexical ambiguity analysis, and corpus linguistics methodology. Porretta’s expert, Dr. William Eggington, testified that the phrase “medical disability benefits” is lexically ambiguous in part because the phrase is exceptionally rare in usage. Utilizing a large-scale dataset, the Corpus of Contemporary American English, Dr. Eggington proved the phrase “medical disability benefits” is not established in American English terminology and does not map to VA disability compensation.

Based on this, together with Porretta’s own credible testimony, the ALJ concluded that Porretta did not intend to falsify MedXPress and reasonably misunderstood question 18.y. The ALJ reversed the FAA’s decision to revoke Porretta’s pilot certificates and ordered their immediate reinstatement.

“I answered that question the same way I answered every other question on that form—honestly, based on my understanding of what it was asking,” said Porretta. “I was working full time and never considered my VA disability compensation a ‘medical disability benefit.’ An expert in forensic linguistics analyzed nearly a billion words of contemporary American English and found the phrase essentially doesn't exist as a defined term. Approximately 4,700 veterans may have answered that question exactly the way I did—based on a reasonable reading of plain English. Most of them probably don’t know they can fight it.”

It’s important to understand that intentional falsification cases are highly fact-specific. Additionally, this ALJ decision was not appealed and, therefore, is not precedent. Also, the FAA amended question 18.y, specifically identifying VA benefits as “medical disability benefits.” Pilots should still be exceptionally careful when completing their MedXPress forms. But, when faced with an enforcement action for intentional falsification, consider using linguistics limbo to prove the questions aren’t as clear as the FAA seems to believe.

photos of AOPA employee Ian Arendt
Ian Arendt
Ian Arendt is an in-house attorney with AOPA’s Legal Services Plan. He provides initial consultations to aircraft owners and pilots facing aviation related legal issues through the LSP. Ian is a private pilot and aircraft owner. The AOPA Legal Services plan is offered as part of AOPA’s Pilot Protection Services.

Related Articles